Nostos and Readwise: What Each Is For, and When Readwise Is the Better Choice

Readwise collects highlights from everywhere and brings them back to you. Nostos keeps the books, the highlights and the draft in one place. Here's how they differ, where Readwise is the better tool, and how to bring a Readwise export into Nostos.

People sometimes ask whether Nostos is a Readwise alternative. Partly. Both keep your highlights, and both care about the reading you have already done. But they start from different places, and for some people Readwise is simply the better tool. This post tries to say which is which.

I built Nostos, so read this knowing that. Everything I say about Readwise comes from its own site as it reads this week.

What Readwise is for

Readwise collects highlights from wherever you make them and brings them back to you. Its pricing page lists imports from Kindle, Apple Books, Kobo “and 40+ sources”, and exports to Notion, Obsidian and others.

The center of it is the Daily Review: an email and an app that show you a few of your highlights each day, using spaced repetition so the ones you want to remember come back at the right time.

Readwise also has Reader, a separate app in the full plan. It saves and reads articles, PDFs, EPUBs, newsletters, RSS feeds, YouTube videos and X threads, and lets you highlight in all of them.

What Nostos is for

Nostos starts with the books. Your EPUBs, PDFs, audiobooks and the paper books on your shelf live in one library, and you read and listen in it. A highlight stays attached to the passage it came from. Notes from different books meet in topics you link with [[Topic]].

Then there is a page to write on. In the Writing Studio you type @, find a passage you kept, and it goes into your draft with its source attached, in one of six citation styles. When you are done, you copy it as rich text into Substack or Google Docs, or export a Word file with real footnotes. The guide to quoting with @ goes through that step by step.

So Readwise is built around bringing highlights back to you. Nostos is built around reading and writing in the same place, with the source never lost on the way.

Where Readwise is the better choice

If you read on a Kindle and want it to sync on its own. Readwise keeps your Kindle highlights up to date in the background. Nostos imports a Kindle’s My Clippings.txt file, which you copy from the device over USB and import again when you want the new ones. Nothing syncs by itself.

If much of your reading is on the web. Reader saves articles, newsletters, RSS and threads, and highlights them. Nostos is a library of books. It does not save web articles, and a Readwise import leaves articles, tweets and podcasts out, because they are not books.

If you want your highlights to come back to you. The Daily Review, with spaced repetition and flashcards on the Highlights plan, is the heart of Readwise. Nostos has no daily review and no reminders. Your highlights wait in the book and in your topics until you go looking, or until you type @ in a draft.

If your notes live in Notion or Obsidian. Readwise exports into those apps and keeps them up to date. Nostos exports notes, highlights and topics as Markdown files, but as a one-off export, not a sync.

If one of these is the main thing you need, Readwise will serve you better, and I would rather you used it.

Where Nostos fits better

If you write from what you read. The part Nostos is built for is the step after the highlight: finding the passage again while you write, putting it into the draft with author, title and year, and sending the draft on with its citations intact. A page number appears only when Nostos is sure of it, from a PDF page. An EPUB position is not a printed page, so Nostos leaves it out rather than guess.

If you want the books too. Nostos reads EPUB and PDF and plays audiobooks, and it keeps the paper books on your shelf, found by ISBN, so their notes have a home. Your highlights sit next to the text they came from, and you can open the page again.

If you want to be able to leave, or to run it yourself. You can export your whole library. Nostos is open source under the AGPLv3, and the same app runs on your own server in one Docker container, for free.

On price, the two are close. Readwise’s Highlights plan is $7.99 a month and the full plan with Reader is $9.99 a month, both billed yearly, with a 30-day trial. Nostos Cloud Standard is $9.99 a month with 15 GB for your books, and its 14-day trial needs no card. Nostos is also young, and I make it on my own, so it has far fewer users than Readwise has.

Using both

They don’t have to compete. Some people will keep Readwise for articles and the daily review, and bring their book highlights into Nostos to write from.

To do that, export your highlights from Readwise as CSV: its export page makes one file with all of them. In Nostos, open Settings → Library → Highlight import and drop that file in.

Nothing is added straight away. Nostos first shows where each book’s highlights will go. Books it can match with certainty are ready. Books it is not sure of ask you to confirm or choose. Books that are not in your library yet can be found or added as new books. Rows that are not from books, such as web articles, tweets and podcasts, are listed with the reason they were left out.

Importing the same file again does not make duplicates, so you can export again later and pick up what is new. If something went into the wrong book, the same window lists your recent imports with an Undo beside each.

From then on the highlights are notes on their books, ready to link into topics and to bring into a draft with @.